This version doesn’t use dice. It uses character abilities, narrative circumstances, and resources to determine outcomes. By using a decision matrix focused on diegetic elements, you maintain structured resolutions without random elements.

Setup

• Define criteria for outcomes based on character traits, skills, and the current narrative.
• Use the decision matrix to evaluate these elements.

Resolution

1. Ask the Question: The player asks a closed question that requires a resolution (e.g., “Is the door unlocked?”).

2. Evaluate Factors:

• Assess relevant character traits and skills.
• Consider the current narrative circumstances.

1. Decision Matrix: Use the decision matrix based on character abilities and narrative context to determine the outcome.

2. Twist Counter: If the answer is “Yes, but…” add a point to the Twist Counter.

Decision Matrix

Guidelines for Resolution

1. Skill and Ability Check:

   • If a character has a relevant skill or ability, the outcome leans towards Yes.
   • If the skill or ability is absent, the outcome leans towards No.

2. Circumstances: Assess the circumstances surrounding the question.

   • Favorable circumstances lean towards Yes, but….
   • Unfavorable circumstances lean towards No, but….

3. Resources and Preparation:

   • Exceptional resources or preparation lean towards Yes, and….
   • Lack of resources or preparation lean towards No, and….

Resolution Example

• Question: “Is the door unlocked?”
• Character Factors: The character is a skilled locksmith (Relevant Skill Present).
• Circumstances: The door is sturdy (Unfavorable Circumstances).
• Resources/Preparation: The character has a complete set of high-quality lockpicking tools (Exceptional Resources).

Outcome: Based on the decision matrix:

• Relevant Skill Present: High influence towards Yes.
• Unfavorable Circumstances: Medium influence towards No, but….
• Exceptional Resources: High influence towards Yes, and….

Final Decision: The door is unlocked easily due to the character’s skill and tools (Yes, and…).